The Sad Truth About Jack and Jill

My mother came back eventually, but the whole situation never felt warm. It felt staged. After she came back my father got an impressive promotion and we were off to Europe, to Berlin.

My mother was fully aware of the abuses that took place. But, she insisted on living behind her own picket fence, where everything is pretty, everything is fine! If we don’t talk about it, it doesn’t exist. 

I began to smell that little stench of staged affection and manufactured presentation. I asked later in life why they reconciled. The answer was deliciously coated with a strange truth. “We didn’t want you and your sister coming from a broken home.” No, instead we came from a home of cold abuse. No one spoke to each other, no one could wait to get out of the house, or out of this life. 

As my father’s career took off, we were forced to do appearances  and photo ops, be seen as a military family having Thanksgiving dinner with the troops, being sociable with the soldiers, act like we like each other, then all leave in separate vehicles to different destinations. 

My father pulled me aside at one of those events, saw the bratty disdain on my face and said, “I’ll take care of that look on your face when we get home….”

The more successful he became, the more power and control fueled him. By the time I was 17 he resented me, hated me. I was smarter than him, taller than him, more perceptive than him. And he hates those people with a passion. His condition was quite Napoleonic. 

By the time I was 17 the beatings had increased because I knew a secret. In order to quiet me, he took control of any strength I had, but I tolerated it. I could see the end of this happening soon, quickly. I would take his lashings, his pointing a shotgun at me, his hitting me with a 2 x 4, because I only had to wait a little while longer to be out from under his control. Then I could be away, far away, and be any body I wanted to be. 

And this is where I pause to write the next line….

The very last time he hit me, I barely flinched, because I wasn’t experiencing at that moment him hitting me…..but, feeling his own father hit him

My father did not have the best childhood. Seven of them lived in a rickety two bedroom house just next to an interstate over path. They didn’t have Christmases. And if they did, my father got socks, underwear, something he needed. Not something that brought joy.

Like his, my father was abusive to the boys in his midst, but overly amorous with the girls. And as he was hitting me that last time, I could see it all playing out in front of me. This man hitting me thinks, feels, that this is how life is supposed to be. It was fortified in his mind at a very young age.  He had been taught this, had observed this behavior as acceptable and normal, and with every moment my skin stung with another smack of the belt on my back, I was realizing it, understanding why he was doing this to me. It is a strange and toxic mix of misunderstandings. I’m going to beat the crap out of you because you’re weak….you’ll either die and prove me right, or you’ll survive and prove me wrong.

He wanted me to be stronger than I was, harder than I was. Do you realize that until I was about 15 when introduced to people, they thought my name was “Grey?” They would ask again, “Did you say, ‘Grey?'” I was too timid to say my own name. Ironically, I was afraid whatever tone or enthusiasm I said my own name with would be met with criticism from my father and another turn at “correcting my behavior.” So I often said my name timidly, head down, eyes staring at the set of boots in front of me….because I had been learning to dislike who I was.

But, that last time he was beating me, I was understanding his anger more and more. What he thought he was giving me in those lessons was a goddamn feeling of self worth. What I was learning, was to doubt myself more and more. That the thoughts, expressions, feelings of who I am are not worth the time exploring. I was to behave as instructed and any deviation is a crime.

Whenever those beatings occurred, my sister would peek her head through our Jack and Jill doors and ask, “Are you ok?”

I’d whimper and cry, “Just leave me alone….GO! CLOSE THE DOOR! LEAVE ME ALONE!!!!”

But, even though thoughts about each other were always in the air, we never spoke of the issues hurting us. That was life.

Before I left Berlin and came back to the states on my own, my sister and I shared a glance. I’ll never forget it. I have to say, we never spoke then about how much we appreciated  the wonderful amount of privacy that those Jack and Jill bedrooms allowed us to share silently with each other. Two caged children, each being hurt in their own cruel way. I felt awful that I was leaving her there alone… one on the other side of the door to run to quietly. Two caged children, unable to speak….but understanding of each other’s pain.

I felt awful the day I left Berlin. I didn’t get a good chance to say goodbye to my friends, but with one glance I was able to say something to my sister.

And that last glance we gave each other as we closed the door for the last time spoke for us. On her end, her eyes swelled with the tears of yearning. “At least he only hits you….”

To which my eyes responded back, “As disgusting as it may be, at least he shows you affection….”

I didn’t hear from her for nearly 20 years….

I guess in the process of healing, I’m told I am to forgive him, bless him with riches, and set him free…..

Dad? If you’re reading this, know that I don’t hate you. I am hurt by you, but I don’t hate you anymore. From the bottom of my heart, I wish you well. I’ve heard you tell me how proud you are  of me and, although I am so pleased to hear that, please don’t congratulate yourself for the man I have become….This man you see before you was my doing. I set you free….You are no longer responsible.

If you appreciate my work and would like for this blog to continue, please donate to help keep it going. I wouldn’t have the courage to do it without your support. 





  1. Damn and wow, Gregory. You bring tears to my eyes. This is profound on so many levels. You are one hell of a writer and a powerful man. Interesting. I have been writing on/working on forgiveness myself the last couple of days, including this morning. Here’s a snippet of what I wrote: Forgive us our debts as we forgive our debtors. To forgive is to let someone off the hook. They are no longer hooked to you by your unforgiveness. You are freed of them in the process. You no longer have to carry them around on your hook.

  2. I hate the “like” button. But, you know how much I love you. How much I love your writing. How much a revel in the joy that you are here to share your writing, your enormous tenderness with us.

  3. It is what it is – My childhood was the same but different. No I guess not it was the same, until I told him “This is the last time your gonna hit me cuz if ya do I’m gonna hit back. You may win a few more times but eventually you are the one who will lose.” He may have yelled at me after that but never again did I feel the sting of his belt. Both my parents are dead now. What was with the parents back then? Why didn’t my mother stop him? A worse thought; it probably still is happening to day as that chain sometimes does not stop. I was married for 19 years never raised a hand to my 2 kids. Then she wanted and got a divorce. After that I came “Out”. My one daughter, after 29 years of marriage was served with papers recently, which entailed her sending me a scathing e mail how the divorce with her mother was all my fault. Go figure. It is what it is! Grey, I guess life is just hard, but the memories that come back as I sit with my chihuahua’s crocheting, many times bring tears to my eyes! Hugs, Tobias Eloy AZ

  4. Your story brings to mind The Great Santini written by Roy Conway. His father was Military. He was beaten mercilessly. He wrote many books and referred to it often. Good luck to you and hope you hang in there.

  5. You are an amazing writer. I am sorry you went through this, but you’ve grown. I am glad you can “forgive” him. I am not to that point. Maybe I can learn from you ~ maybe.

  6. My dad was military, too. I can’t say it was much different…
    I’m sorry.
    I took the good things from that life and applied it -I left the bad stuff behind. I wouldn’t want to live that life again, oh heck no…
    I often say, “I guess my parents did the best they could.” I’m not excusing them, It’s my way of trying to figure out why…

  7. I miss you and I remember those jack and jill moments. I never thought that you left me behind. I was jealous of you being able to leave. I had to go through some extreme measures and manipulations. I hurt and used others to leave. But I didn’t know at that time how much it has impacted our lives. I had no coping skills except for one and we know how that turned out.I had to fess up and be honest. Went to therapy and treatment for 3 years.What we have is a yearning to be closer as brother and sister ❤️ without fear!
    Love you, Jessica
    Please email me

  8. Gregory, you have done a marvelous job of overcoming the parental abuse. You have created a talented, sensitive, compassionate man. Be proud of yourself and your accomplishments. Above all, be good to yourself.

  9. Oh, Gregory, I have tears in my eyes for the traumatic childhood you & your sister lived through. You are both survivors. I had an abusive parent, different kind of abuse than your family’s. Unlike you, I had some parental protection. I can’t imagine the scars you & your sister carry. I hope you are getting therapy for your trauma. It’s never too late to deal with past pain that can drag itself into the present.

    You are fortunate your sister doesn’t live in denial as does my brother. I’ll share my Dad’s story about forgiveness from his life. His father abandoned them when he was 9. It took 2 years for my grandmother to be able to divorce granddad. In those years divorces were very difficult to get. As a result, grandma had to sent her 9 children to live among 3 of her siblings. MY dad was 16 when he decided to forgive HIS dad. He told me forgiving his father was something he did for himself, less for his father. Forgiving his dad enabled him to lay down his anger and resentment towards him. Ultimately, my brother & I grew up knowing our grandfather. The rest of our cousins didn’t know him at all.

    Take care of yourself, Gregory. Do what you need to do for your own healing.

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in: Logo

You are commenting using your account. Log Out /  Change )

Google photo

You are commenting using your Google account. Log Out /  Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out /  Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out /  Change )

Connecting to %s

This site uses Akismet to reduce spam. Learn how your comment data is processed.